the GPU consumption trained on ImageNet

[vtddggg]

when training on 1000 classes imagenet, the GPU memory of prompts seems very large and results in the Out Of Memory error on 16GB GPU Card.
How to solve this problem?

[KaiyangZhou]

reduce the batch size then

just realize mainly the text encoder causes the problem :(

hmm, it's a tough question then

ideally you would need a GPU with 32GB memory

for 16 GB GPUs you might need to modify the source code, somehow (no idea what to do, yet)

[vtddggg]

Yes, it exceeds 16GB even using batch-size=1. Unfortunately, I do not have a GPU with 32GB memory 😂
Maybe I should think other ways to reduce the memory consumption.

[XiaoCode-er]

@KaiyangZhou 麻烦问一下论文中res50在imagenet上的实验，需要几张卡，memory需要多大？一般训练多久？

[KaiyangZhou]

@XiaoCode-er

• 1 gpu card
• 32gb memory
• few hours

[RenShuhuai-Andy]

@KaiyangZhou
Hi, I have encountered the same problem.
Can you kindly provide the checkpoints of CoOp on ImageNet?

[KaiyangZhou]

The pre-trained weights have just been released. Please see the readme file

[limycml]

@KaiyangZhou

Thank you for sharing the code,
please ask, is it possible for one RTX3090 24Gb?

[KaiyangZhou]

is it possible for one RTX3090 24Gb?

basically the memory consumption increases with the number of classes (for prompt learning methods)

24gb might be sufficient for most datasets except imagenet

[tingxueronghua]

Hi Kaiyang, I think with a slight modification, the model could run on ImageNet if using more than one graphic cards.

For CoOp, just change the code on line 257 of coopy.py from "self.model = nn.DataParallel(self.model)" to "self.model.text_encoder = nn.DataParallel(self.model.text_encoder)". I tested it on 1-shot ImageNet with 4 graphic cards, and found that each card only consumed around 8GB memory. Compared with my previous experiments on a single card, the accuracy even increases a little bit :)

The image_encoder does not need to be run parallelly at least for CoOp because it does not require backward propagation and only has a small batch size.

reduce the batch size then

just realize mainly the text encoder causes the problem :(

hmm, it's a tough question then

ideally you would need a GPU with 32GB memory

for 16 GB GPUs you might need to modify the source code, somehow (no idea what to do, yet)

[tingxueronghua]

I had to say the way using DataParallel on CustomCLIP cannot save GPU memory on each card at all...

[KaiyangZhou]

No. DataParallel won't help.

The problem for imagenet is that the 1,000 classes would create a huge memory consumption for the text encoder. So for smaller datasets with fewer classes, the problem is gone. And the tricky thing is, you can't split the classes into two gpus because in doing so the attention in the transformer model won't work properly. Hmm ...

[tingxueronghua]

No. DataParallel won't help.

The problem for imagenet is that the 1,000 classes would create a huge memory consumption for the text encoder. So for smaller datasets with fewer classes, the problem is gone. And the tricky thing is, you can't split the classes into two gpus because in doing so the attention in the transformer model won't work properly. Hmm ...

In fact, DataParallel could save memory if used correctly. To be short, it is not the class tensors in the last layer themselves caused the problem, but the intermediate tensors, gradients and the computation graph.

If the code is modified as mentioned above, all the intermediate tensors and most of the gradients could be scattered to different GPUs. And finally, when the model on each card get the final text features, we can collect them to a single card then.

[tingxueronghua]

Emm, I am not sure whether you noticed. I indeed have run experiments and verified the method's effectiveness...

I tested it on 1-shot ImageNet with 4 graphic cards, and found that each card only consumed around 8GB memory.

[tingxueronghua]

No. DataParallel won't help.

The problem for imagenet is that the 1,000 classes would create a huge memory consumption for the text encoder. So for smaller datasets with fewer classes, the problem is gone. And the tricky thing is, you can't split the classes into two gpus because in doing so the attention in the transformer model won't work properly. Hmm ...

I do not understand why the attention in the transformer model would have problems. I think the attention mechanism only work within each sample, and there is no attention between samples in a batch.

[KaiyangZhou]

Oh, my bad. I thought you were talking about another approach. The attention thing doesn't matter then.

[zaiyuzhohg]

在1000级imagenet上训练时，提示的GPU内存似乎很大，导致16GB GPU卡出现内存不足错误。如何解决这个问题？

I want to know why doesn't CoOp have this problem?

[zaiyuzhohg]

I want to know why doesn't CoOp have this problem?

那就减少批量

才意识到主要是文本编码器导致的问题:(

嗯，这是个很难回答的问题

理想情况下，你需要一个32GB内存的GPU

对于16 GB的GPU，你可能需要以某种方式修改源代码(还不知道该怎么做)

I want to know why doesn't CoOp have this problem? one RTX3090 24Gb is enough for coop