Discogs plugin gives wrong order of tracks after searching with release ID

[jmizv]

Hi,
does anybody know whether this is an bug? I used this command

beet import -m C:\folder\HavocFrist15Years\

to import this CD rip to my library. As I wanted to use the discogs ID, I entered 788558 but this gives me a slightly wrong order and I have no idea why. The folder contains all 38 needed mp3 files, named 01 Track01.mp3, 02 Track02.mp3, etc.:

C:\folder\HavocFrist15Years (38 items)
Finding tags for album " - ".
Candidates:
1. Sammy Davis Jr. - Sammy Davis Jr.'s Greatest Hits (23.4%) (unmatched tracks, tracks, album, ...) (Discogs, Vinyl, 1968, US, Reprise Records, RS 6291)
2. Mike Ness - Cheating At Solitaire (12.7%) (tracks, unmatched tracks, album, ...) (Discogs, CD, 1999, US, Time Bomb Recordings, 70930-43524-2)
3. Greg Beato - Apron EP (5.7%) (unmatched tracks, tracks, album, ...) (Discogs, Vinyl, 2013, UK, Apron Records, APRON005)
4. Ministry - Twelve Inch Singles (1981-1984) (4.8%) (unmatched tracks, tracks, album, ...) (Discogs, CD, 1987, US, Wax Trax! Records, WAXCD 035)
5. INXS - Welcome To Wherever You Are (4.2%) (tracks, unmatched tracks, album, ...) (Discogs, CD, 1992, Europe, Mercury, 512-507-2)
# selection (default 1), Skip, Use as-is, as Tracks, Group albums,
Enter search, enter Id, aBort? I
Enter release ID: 788558
Correcting tags from:
    (unknown album)
To:
    The First 15 Years - 2006 Record Sampler
URL:
    https://www.discogs.com/release/788558-Various-The-First-15-Years-2006-Record-Sampler
(Similarity: 40.0%) (tracks, album) (Discogs, CD, 2006, US, Havoc Records, HC2000)
 * 01 Track01.mp3 (#0) -> Police Sirens (#1) (title)
 * 02 Track02.mp3 (#0) -> Hardcore Del 2 (#2) (title)
 * 26 Track26.mp3 (#0) -> Secret Police (#3) (title)
 * 20 Track20.mp3 (#0) -> Now We Are Dead (#4) (title)
 * 05 Track05.mp3 (#0) -> Den Mörka Floden I Vårat Hjärta (#5) (title)
 * 06 Track06.mp3 (#0) -> Utanförskapet (#6) (title)
 * 07 Track07.mp3 (#0) -> Bottom Line (#7) (title)
 * 08 Track08.mp3 (#0) -> Uniforms (#8) (title)
 * 09 Track09.mp3 (#0) -> Everybody Hates Me (#9) (title)
 * 15 Track15.mp3 (#0) -> Through Being Cute (#10) (title)
 * 11 Track11.mp3 (#0) -> Walk The Line (#11) (title)
 * 12 Track12.mp3 (#0) -> Fear (#12) (title)
 * 13 Track13.mp3 (#0) -> Immaculate Deception (#13) (title)
 * 14 Track14.mp3 (#0) -> Illusio (#14) (title)
 * 37 Track37.mp3 (#0) -> If The Leaders Are Impotent Then Only The People Can Rise (#15) (title)
 * 16 Track16.mp3 (#0) -> Crucify (#16) (title)
 * 17 Track17.mp3 (#0) -> Jag Mott Dig (#17) (title)
 * 18 Track18.mp3 (#0) -> War Path (#18) (title)
 * 19 Track19.mp3 (#0) -> Genug Ist Genug (#19) (title)
 * 33 Track33.mp3 (#0) -> Attack With A Gasmask (#20) (title)
 * 21 Track21.mp3 (#0) -> DS 13 (#21) (title)
 * 22 Track22.mp3 (#0) -> Lie (#22) (title)
 * 23 Track23.mp3 (#0) -> Why Don't You Fucking Die? (#23) (title)
 * 28 Track28.mp3 (#0) -> Make The Skynerd Stop (#24) (title)
 * 25 Track25.mp3 (#0) -> Just Another Day (#25) (title)
 * 24 Track24.mp3 (#0) -> Give The Kids What They Want (#26) (title)
 * 27 Track27.mp3 (#0) -> Two Fisted Tales (#27) (title)
 * 29 Track29.mp3 (#0) -> Vaihtoehto (#28) (title)
 * 31 Track31.mp3 (#0) -> Sotaa (#29) (title)
 * 30 Track30.mp3 (#0) -> Alien Boy (#30) (title)
 * 36 Track36.mp3 (#0) -> Days Ahead (#31) (title)
 * 32 Track32.mp3 (#0) -> Age Of Fear (#32) (title)
 * 34 Track34.mp3 (#0) -> Fuck Nazi Sympathy (#33) (title)
 * 10 Track10.mp3 (#0) -> Faith Not Sight (#34) (title)
 * 35 Track35.mp3 (#0) -> Enforced Orthodoxy (#35) (title)
 * 04 Track04.mp3 (#0) -> Power Songs For The Kids (#36) (title)
 * 03 Track03.mp3 (#0) -> Punch Line (#37) (title)
 * 38 Track38.mp3 (#0) -> Wealth And Power (#38) (title)
Apply, More candidates, Skip, Use as-is, as Tracks, Group albums,
Enter search, enter Id, aBort?

Please note that while the first two mp3 files are correctly assigned to the two first tracks, directly after them are coming the wrong tracks.

Any ideas what's going on here?

PS C:\...> beet version
beets version 1.6.0
Python version 3.10.1
plugins: discogs

[sampsyo]

Here, beets doesn't have much to go on because the files don't have existing metadata; it does not use the names of the files to do ordering by default.

You may consider enabling the fromfilename plugin, but I'm not 100% sure it will work with this pattern of file names.