Chokidar 4.0.1 not responding to add change or unlink events in Bun 1.1.27

[ridhwaans]

Describe the bug

A clear and concise description of what the bug is.

Versions (please complete the following information):

• Chokidar version 4.0.1
• Bun 1.1.27
• OS version: Ubuntu 24.04.1 LTS on Windows 10 x86_64

To Reproduce:

Steps to reproduce the behavior. Include filename and chokidar config.

Ideally prove a problem by isolating and making it reproducible with a very short sample program, which you could paste here:

// apps/server
import { env } from '@project/env';
import { fileWatcher } from '@project/core';

fileWatcher(env.DIR1_PATH, env.DIR2_PATH, env.DIR3_PATH);

const PORT = 3004;
app.listen(PORT, () => {
  console.log(`Listening on http://localhost:${PORT}`);
});

The above is from apps/server and runs via bun --watch run src/index.ts
It uses chokidar wrapper from packages/core below

// packages/core
import chokidar from 'chokidar';

var fileSystem = [] as any;
var ready: any;

const fileWatcher = (dir1Path, dir2Path, dir3Path) => {
  if (new Set([dir1Path, dir2Path, dir3Path]).size != 3) {
    throw 'Each directory must be in a different subdirectory and cannot share the same directory path(s)';
  }
  
  const watcher = chokidar.watch(
    [dir1Path as string, dir2Path as string, dir3Path as string],
    {
      ignored: /(^|[\/\\])\../, // ignore dotfiles
      persistent: true,
    },
  );

  watcher.on('ready', () => {
    console.log('Initial scan complete. Ready for changes');
    ready = true;
    ready && sync();
  });

  watcher
    .on('add', (path) => {
      console.log(`File ${path} has been added`);
      fileSystem.push(path);
      ready && sync();
    })
    .on('change', (path) => {
      console.log(`File ${path} has been changed`);
    })
    .on('unlink', (path) => {
      console.log(`File ${path} has been removed`);
      fileSystem = fileSystem.filter((e: any) => e !== path);
      ready && sync();
    });
    
    const sync = async () => {
         fileSystem && (await upsertRow(fileSystem[fileSystem .length - 1]))
         ...
      };
  return watcher;
 }

However, when I add new files, rename existing files or remove existing files from any of the three directories in the chokidar array, it does not initiate the watch events
I know because there is no console log when there is filesystem activity

It was working before, not sure when it broke. Havent tested in a while

Most valuable could be one or more test cases for test.js to demonstrate the problem.

Expected behavior
when I add new files, rename existing files or remove existing files from any of the three directories in the chokidar array, it should call the add, unlink or change events (watcher.on())

[ridhwaans]

Is my ignore pattern wrong?
I used it from the docs from the previous version (^3.6.0)
However when I removed the ignored property, it starts delisting all previously watched files which is wrong
The three target directories in the chokidar array can have subdirectories. Which means any files added/removed recursively should be picked up by chokidar

[ridhwaans]

Reverted to ^3.6.0 but does not work still (on Bun 1.1.27 / bun --watch run )

[43081j]

I tried your code locally and cant seem to reproduce it

I'm on Linux fwiw. I copied the code across, and made 3 directories with one existing file in each

I then tried a rename, remove and addition. all 3 triggered the right events for me

it could be OS specific, maybe 🤔

[ridhwaans]

@43081j are your directories on a volume mount?
In my system I have Ubuntu installed in windows on \\wsl.localhost\Ubuntu, a windows network
then, the three directories are on another drive and my chokidar array is [ '/mnt/d/gas', '/mnt/d/solid', '/mnt/d/liquid' ]

The interesting part is that watcher.on('ready' works, but the other ones fail

using bun

[43081j]

I've found wsl filesystem events to be very sketchy in general

I used to use a similar setup (code on the windows mount, but running commands in wsl). Native watch would miss a lot of events (without chokidar).

I moved to having my code in wsl and accessing it from windows (i.e the reverse)

You could try throw a script together to fs.watch one of those directories recursively and log the events out. See if node itself even sees them

[ridhwaans]

the code is in wsl, sorry if that wasnt clear. i also run within wsl (i think?) in linux terminal

i created a test which targets three folders within ubuntu rather than three directories on windows or an external drive (NTFS). then, chokidar and everything works as expected

in my case i cant change the directories because the ubuntu partition is too small to hold all the data

[43081j]

Yes sorry that's what I meant

Within WSL, if you watch a directory on the windows mount, node seems to miss a lot of events

If you can test it using fs.watch directly, you will know if that is true. e.g create an fs watcher with recursive: true and just log any events that fire. If some never turn up, it is what I suspected. If they all trigger as expected, it may be chokidar's problem

[ridhwaans]

I recently tried on a mac filesystem (15.1 Sequoia ) . The target directories were on /Volumes/volume/... .

 watcher.on('ready', () => {

The chokidar client would not detect the 'ready' event, and it couldnt be tested. weird.

Edit: mac on mac (app & watch directory)

[43081j]

I suspect WSL just isn't very reliable cross filesystem still

I moved all my code to the Linux container for this reason (both rollup and webpack barely triggered in watch mode since the events go missing inside windows)