Weather info refactor #366
Conversation
…no as default provider
- Introduced new weather provider implementations for OpenWeather and YrNo, including data fetching and response handling. - Added standardized icon mapping for weather conditions, enabling consistent icon representation across different providers. - Implemented functions to convert provider-specific weather codes to standardized icon codes and retrieve appropriate weather icons based on conditions and time of day. - Enhanced the weather service to support dynamic provider selection based on configuration settings. - Included detailed SVG icons for various weather conditions and times of day, improving the visual representation of weather data.
- Modified WeatherSettings struct to include PollInterval and Debug fields, enhancing configurability. - Updated default settings in defaults.go to reflect new weather configuration structure. - Refactored migration logic to set default provider and poll interval. - Removed legacy OpenWeather validation and added new validation for weather settings. - Adjusted YAML configuration to align with the new structure, ensuring compatibility with the updated settings. - Improved code clarity and maintainability by consolidating weather-related settings.
- Replaced existing save logic in SaveDailyEvents and SaveHourlyWeather with upsert functionality to streamline data insertion and updates. - Enhanced error handling for database operations, providing clearer error messages for failures. - Added basic validation for hourly weather data to ensure valid timestamps before saving. - Improved query structure in GetHourlyWeather and LatestHourlyWeather for better readability and error reporting.
…dling - Replaced custom TimeOfDay type with a new implementation from the weather package for consistency. - Updated weather-related logic in Detections and addWeatherAndTimeOfDay methods to utilize the new weather provider settings. - Refactored GetWeatherIconFunc and GetSunPositionIconFunc to leverage the weather package for icon retrieval based on weather conditions and time of day. - Enhanced CalculateTimeOfDay and TimeOfDayToInt methods to use the weather package's functionality, improving maintainability and clarity.
…ta providers - Removed legacy OpenWeather settings and introduced a new Weather section for configuring weather data collection. - Added options for selecting weather providers, including OpenWeather and Yr.no, with relevant API key and endpoint configurations. - Enhanced user interface with tooltips and conditional notes based on selected weather provider. - Streamlined the settings structure for better maintainability and clarity in weather data management.
…rvice - Replaced legacy OpenWeather integration with a new weather service that supports dynamic provider selection. - Modified weather polling logic to check for enabled providers based on updated settings structure. - Enhanced error handling during weather service initialization to improve robustness. - Streamlined the integration of weather data collection within the RealtimeAnalysis function.
…con retrieval - Introduced a new mapping for standardized icon codes to human-readable descriptions, improving user understanding of weather conditions. - Added a function to retrieve descriptions based on icon codes, enhancing the usability of the weather icon system. - Updated the GetWeatherIcon function to return a default icon with improved SVG dimensions for better visual consistency. - Enhanced the time of day icon retrieval to ensure consistent SVG sizes across different time representations.
…te functions - Introduced GetWeatherDescriptionFunc to provide human-readable descriptions for weather codes. - Updated GetTemplateFunctions to include the new weather description function, enhancing the template's capability to display weather information. - This change improves user experience by offering clearer insights into weather conditions through descriptions.
- Changed the weather icon retrieval to use the correct icon code for improved accuracy. - Updated the display of weather descriptions to provide clearer information based on the weather icon. - This enhancement improves the user interface by ensuring that weather data is presented more intuitively.
…vice - Eliminated debug print statements in the OpenWeatherProvider and Service fetchAndSave methods to clean up the code.
- Updated the FetchWeather method in YrNoProvider to format latitude and longitude with three decimal places
- Eliminated YrNoSettings from WeatherSettings struct, simplifying the weather configuration. - Updated GetWeatherSettings method to remove references to YrNo, focusing on OpenWeather integration. - Adjusted migration logic to reflect the removal of Yr.no settings, ensuring compatibility with the new structure.
- Added migration logic to convert old weather settings to the new structure, ensuring compatibility with the updated configuration.
- Eliminated debug print statement in GetWeatherIconFunc to clean up the code and improve readability.
|
Warning Rate limit exceeded@tphakala has exceeded the limit for the number of commits or files that can be reviewed per hour. Please wait 11 minutes and 13 seconds before requesting another review. ⌛ How to resolve this issue?After the wait time has elapsed, a review can be triggered using the We recommend that you space out your commits to avoid hitting the rate limit. 🚦 How do rate limits work?CodeRabbit enforces hourly rate limits for each developer per organization. Our paid plans have higher rate limits than the trial, open-source and free plans. In all cases, we re-allow further reviews after a brief timeout. Please see our FAQ for further information. 📒 Files selected for processing (2)
WalkthroughThis pull request introduces a comprehensive refactoring of the weather data handling system in BirdNET-Go. The changes replace the existing OpenWeather-specific implementation with a more flexible, provider-agnostic weather service. A new Changes
Sequence DiagramsequenceDiagram
participant App as BirdNET-Go App
participant WS as Weather Service
participant Provider as Weather Provider
participant DataStore as Database
App->>WS: Initialize Weather Service
WS->>Provider: Select Provider
App->>WS: Start Polling
loop Periodic Weather Fetch
WS->>Provider: Fetch Weather Data
Provider-->>WS: Return Weather Data
WS->>DataStore: Save Weather Data
end
Possibly related PRs
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 4
🧹 Nitpick comments (15)
internal/weather/provider_openweather.go (1)
51-127: Consider a more granular retry approach or immediate resource cleanup.
The pattern of deferringresp.Body.Close()within the loop can accumulate multiple defers if multiple retries occur. Although these defers will eventually run, it is often considered clearer to close the response body within the same iteration before continuing. This approach avoids stacking multiple defers and clarifies resource-lifetime handling.internal/weather/provider_yrno.go (1)
47-145: Return typed “no new data” errors to distinguish from actual failures.
If the response is304("Not Modified"), the method returns a generic error. You may want a typed error (e.g.,ErrNoNewData) to handle it differently upstream instead of logging it as an error internally.+var ErrNoNewData = errors.New("no new data available") ... if resp.StatusCode == http.StatusNotModified { - return nil, fmt.Errorf("no new data available") + return nil, ErrNoNewData }internal/weather/weather.go (3)
23-36: Consider doc comments for WeatherData fields.
This struct forms the core of weather data across providers. Adding Go doc comments clarifies the meaning and typical ranges of each field, improving maintainability for future contributors.
141-181: Graceful polling design.
The ticker-based loop with a configurable interval is straightforward and easy to maintain. For large scale usage, consider backoff strategies or separate concurrency controls if the weather API usage grows.
183-231: Consolidate debug logging.
The debug logging is verbose and scattered throughout the method. Consider using a structured logging approach or bundling messages into a single log entry to avoid spamming logs, especially in production.internal/weather/providers.go (1)
13-17: Consider doc comments for provider structs.
DocumentingYrNoProviderandOpenWeatherProviderclarifies their responsibilities, especially since both implement theProviderinterface in distinct ways.internal/httpcontroller/handlers/weather.go (1)
32-36: Add a fallback for incomplete sun event data.
Ifsuncalc.SunEventTimesis missing some fields or a time is unexpectedly zero-value, ensureCalculateTimeOfDaycan handle it gracefully.internal/weather/icon_codes.go (2)
45-57: Consider clarifying day/night in descriptions.These human-readable descriptions do not differentiate between day and night. If your application or UI needs distinct textual clues (e.g., "Clear Sky (Night)"), expanding these descriptions might improve clarity.
59-72: Add logging on fallback icon code usage.Returning
"01"as a fallback ensures that unmapped codes do not break the application. However, to ease troubleshooting, consider logging a debug or warning message to flag unexpected provider codes.func GetStandardIconCode(code string, provider string) IconCode { switch provider { ... } - return "01" // default to clear sky if no mapping found + log.Printf("Warning: Unmapped %s code '%s', defaulting to '01'", provider, code) + return "01" }internal/httpcontroller/template_functions.go (1)
51-51: Ensure safe handling of missing weather data.The new
"weatherDescription"template function is valuable. Consider explicitly handling cases where the weather data might be unavailable or incomplete, and return a default placeholder string or an empty string to avoid confusion in the UI.internal/conf/defaults.go (1)
101-120: Clean up commented-out legacy code.The old OpenWeather block is commented out. If it’s definitively deprecated, removing it entirely would reduce confusion. If you plan to reintroduce it later, adding a clarifying comment about its future use would be helpful. Also, using
"yrno"as the default provider with a 60-minute poll interval appears reasonable.internal/conf/validate.go (1)
281-288: Add checks for valid provider names (if relevant).
validateWeatherSettingsdiligently enforces a minimumPollInterval. If you expect only certain supported providers (e.g.,yrno,openweather), you might also validate thatsettings.Provideris recognized. This can help catch typos or invalid configurations early.func validateWeatherSettings(settings *WeatherSettings) error { + validProviders := []string{"yrno", "openweather"} + providerIsValid := false + for _, p := range validProviders { + if settings.Provider == p { + providerIsValid = true + break + } + } + if !providerIsValid { + return fmt.Errorf("invalid weather provider: %s", settings.Provider) + } if settings.PollInterval < 15 { return fmt.Errorf("weather poll interval must be at least 15 minutes, got %d", settings.PollInterval) } return nil }internal/weather/icons.go (1)
20-58: Comprehensive icon mapping
The definition of SVG icons for different conditions and times of day is thorough. Good separation of concerns, but consider extracting the repetitive<svg>code into a shared library if it grows too large.internal/conf/config.go (1)
102-102: Clarify rationale for legacy support.The comment indicates that
Enabledis for legacy support. Consider adding a note or date on when to remove or retire this field if it is truly temporary.views/settings/integrationSettings.html (1)
338-468: Dynamic weather settings panel is well-structured.The reactive Alpine.js block for weather settings effectively toggles provider options. This design makes it easy to introduce new weather providers in the future. Ensure the
pollIntervalvalue has sufficient validation server-side to prevent excessively frequent polling or unintentional resource usage.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
📒 Files selected for processing (20)
internal/analysis/realtime.go(3 hunks)internal/conf/config.go(3 hunks)internal/conf/config.yaml(1 hunks)internal/conf/defaults.go(1 hunks)internal/conf/validate.go(2 hunks)internal/datastore/interfaces.go(2 hunks)internal/httpcontroller/handlers/detections.go(4 hunks)internal/httpcontroller/handlers/weather.go(1 hunks)internal/httpcontroller/handlers/weather_icons.go(0 hunks)internal/httpcontroller/template_functions.go(1 hunks)internal/openweather/openweather.go(0 hunks)internal/weather/icon_codes.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/icons.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/provider_common.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/provider_openweather.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/provider_yrno.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/providers.go(1 hunks)internal/weather/weather.go(1 hunks)views/fragments/listDetections.html(1 hunks)views/settings/integrationSettings.html(1 hunks)
💤 Files with no reviewable changes (2)
- internal/httpcontroller/handlers/weather_icons.go
- internal/openweather/openweather.go
✅ Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- internal/weather/provider_common.go
🧰 Additional context used
🪛 yamllint (1.35.1)
internal/conf/config.yaml
[error] 92-92: trailing spaces
(trailing-spaces)
🔇 Additional comments (36)
internal/weather/provider_yrno.go (1)
18-45: Validate presence of expected fields in Yr.no response.
Similar to OpenWeather, Yr.no generally provides a well-structured response, but the code assumes presence ofTimeseries[0].Data.Next1Hours. Consider verifying thatlen(Properties.Timeseries) > 0andNext1Hoursis not nil to avoid potential runtime panics if the API response changes or is incomplete.internal/weather/weather.go (3)
63-82: Ensure fallback logic matches PR summary.
The PR summary mentions an automatic fallback to Yr.no if no provider is specified, but here you explicitly error out when the provider doesn't match "yrno" or "openweather." Confirm that upstream code always sets a valid provider or add a fallback case.
84-129: Validate dailyEvents.ID before creating HourlyWeather records.
While it’s presumably guaranteed thats.db.SaveDailyEventssetsdailyEvents.ID, you might add a quick check to confirmdailyEvents.ID != 0if that’s relevant to your DB constraints. Failing early can prevent unexpected foreign key issues.
130-139: Good practice on fundamental validation.
Basic checks for impossible weather conditions (e.g., temperature below absolute zero) are helpful to catch data errors.internal/weather/providers.go (2)
3-6: Explicitly reference theYrNoProviderstruct usage.
This factory approach is clean. IfYrNoProviderneeds additional fields later (e.g., caching or credentials), ensure you handle them inNewYrNoProvider.
8-11: Parallel structure for OpenWeather.
Similarly,NewOpenWeatherProvideradheres well to the same factory pattern, making it easy to add more providers in the future.internal/httpcontroller/handlers/weather.go (2)
12-23: Caution with HTML generation.
Returningtemplate.HTMLcan be safe if icons are strictly sanitized and controlled. Otherwise, consider escaping or validating to prevent XSS.
42-52: Consistent naming for weather codes.
Here we strip the suffix and fallback to the first two characters. Confirm the same approach is used across all icon or description lookups so that everything remains uniform.internal/weather/icon_codes.go (2)
1-4: Excellent introduction and domain-specific naming.The package declaration, documentation comment, and
IconCodetype make the file purpose clear. It's a good practice to include a brief explanation regarding the rationale behind standardizing icon codes (e.g., to streamline template rendering or front-end logic).
23-43: Provider-specific mappings look good.The
OpenWeatherToIconmap aligns with commonly used codes. No immediate issues are apparent, but it might be beneficial to confirm that all OpenWeather codes are covered or at least log any unmapped codes for better debugging.internal/conf/validate.go (1)
65-69: Weather validation seamlessly integrated.This new step in
ValidateSettingsensures that weather-specific settings do not slip past validation. Just confirm that callingvalidateWeatherSettingsis sufficient for all possible providers (e.g., if a new provider is introduced later, you can expand the validation logic).internal/analysis/realtime.go (2)
23-23: Imports aligned with new weather integration
No concerns here: the addition of theweatherpackage import is consistent with the new architecture.
147-147: Flexible weather provider check
Great job ensuring the provider can be toggled dynamically by comparing against"none". This is a clean replacement for the olderOpenWeatherchecks.internal/httpcontroller/handlers/detections.go (4)
15-15: New weather package import
This import is consistent with the updated module approach. No issues.
34-34: Refactor to use TimeOfDay from weather package
Switching from a local type toweather.TimeOfDayis a clean approach to centralizing code around the new weather structures.
87-88: User-facing weather enablement check
Nicely replaces the old approach. The variable nameweatherEnabledclarifies that we only proceed if a valid provider is configured.
235-235: Consistent weather provider check in helper method
Thanks for ensuring consistency in theaddWeatherAndTimeOfDayfunction. This helps reduce conditional confusion.internal/weather/icons.go (8)
1-2: New package introduction
The newweatherpackage design is neat; it's modular and helps clarify weather-related logic.
10-18: TimeOfDay enum
Defining a clear enum for time-of-day states improves readability and helps avoid magic constants. Good job.
59-65: TimeOfDay icons
These icons nicely mirror the approach used for actual weather conditions. This cohesive design fosters consistency across the UI.
67-78: GetWeatherIcon
Great fallback logic returning a default icon if a specific time-of-day icon isn't found. Very user-friendly approach.
80-86: GetIconDescription
Straightforward, with a clear "Unknown" fallback. This is good for future-proofing.
88-94: GetTimeOfDayIcon
Same fallback logic asGetWeatherIcon. Consistency is key. Good job.
96-110: CalculateTimeOfDay
Nice usage of sun event boundaries to define the time of day. The logic is both clear and functionally sound. No concerns.
112-126: StringToTimeOfDay
Straightforward conversion function. ReturningDayby default is reasonable.internal/datastore/interfaces.go (5)
408-414: Upsert approach for daily events
Switching toFirstOrCreatewithAssignhelps reduce complexity. The error handling is also improved.
431-433: Hourly weather validation
It's good to prevent zero-time data from polluting the database. Clear and direct error message.
435-443: Upsert for hourly weather
Same improvement pattern as daily events. Brief, no-nonsense approach.
451-457: Sorted query for hourly weather
Ascending order ensures consistent retrieval. Logged error is concise and meaningful.
466-474: Graceful handling for LatestHourlyWeather
Covers both record-not-found and generic error cases. Nicely done.internal/conf/config.go (4)
92-99: Good struct organization for weather settings.Defining a separate
WeatherSettingsstruct consolidates weather-related configuration cleanly. The documentation string on line 92 is helpful, though consider reiterating thatPollIntervalis in minutes.
158-158: YAML ignore annotation looks fine.Ignoring
OpenWeatherin YAML is appropriate to avoid conflicting with the newWeatherSettingsapproach. Code is consistent with the legacy conversation in line 102.
165-165: Clear addition for weather configuration.Adding
Weather WeatherSettingsinRealtimeSettingshelps unify real-time processing with the new weather structure.
556-569: Logical fallback for weather settings.The
GetWeatherSettingsmethod checks the newWeather.Providerfirst, then falls back toOpenWeatherif enabled, otherwise defaults to "yrno." This ensures backward compatibility. If disabling weather is needed, ensure"none"is set to avoid the Yr.no fallback.Would you like a verification script that checks for references to
"none"usage in the codebase to confirm correct handling of disabled weather?internal/conf/config.yaml (1)
89-97: Implementation of new weather section is consistent with the refactor.The
weathersubsection withprovider,pollinterval,debug, and nestedopenweatherfields centralizes configuration neatly. The default choice of Yr.no matches the refactor’s stated intent.🧰 Tools
🪛 yamllint (1.35.1)
[error] 92-92: trailing spaces
(trailing-spaces)
views/fragments/listDetections.html (1)
94-95: Template function usage is appropriate.Switching from
.Weather.WeatherMaintoweatherIconandweatherDescriptionis a neat approach to improve clarity. This effectively decouples display logic from raw data fields, aligning with the new weather service.
| // OpenWeatherResponse represents the structure of weather data returned by the OpenWeather API | ||
| type OpenWeatherResponse struct { | ||
| Coord struct { | ||
| Lon float64 `json:"lon"` | ||
| Lat float64 `json:"lat"` | ||
| } `json:"coord"` | ||
| Weather []struct { | ||
| ID int `json:"id"` | ||
| Main string `json:"main"` | ||
| Description string `json:"description"` | ||
| Icon string `json:"icon"` | ||
| } `json:"weather"` | ||
| Main struct { | ||
| Temp float64 `json:"temp"` | ||
| FeelsLike float64 `json:"feels_like"` | ||
| TempMin float64 `json:"temp_min"` | ||
| TempMax float64 `json:"temp_max"` | ||
| Pressure int `json:"pressure"` | ||
| Humidity int `json:"humidity"` | ||
| } `json:"main"` | ||
| Visibility int `json:"visibility"` | ||
| Wind struct { | ||
| Speed float64 `json:"speed"` | ||
| Deg int `json:"deg"` | ||
| Gust float64 `json:"gust"` | ||
| } `json:"wind"` | ||
| Clouds struct { | ||
| All int `json:"all"` | ||
| } `json:"clouds"` | ||
| Dt int64 `json:"dt"` | ||
| Sys struct { | ||
| Country string `json:"country"` | ||
| Sunrise int64 `json:"sunrise"` | ||
| Sunset int64 `json:"sunset"` | ||
| } `json:"sys"` | ||
| Name string `json:"name"` | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codebase verification
Direct access to weatherData.Weather[0] could cause panic
The code directly accesses weatherData.Weather[0] without checking if the array is empty, which could lead to a panic. The OpenWeather API documentation typically guarantees at least one weather condition, but it's better to be defensive in our code. The current implementation in FetchWeather method needs bounds checking before accessing the array.
internal/weather/provider_openweather.go: Add bounds checking before accessingweatherData.Weather[0]in the return statement (around line 127-128).
The suggested fix in the review comment is appropriate, though I would modify it slightly to match the current codebase structure:
+ // Default values in case weather array is empty
+ description := "N/A"
+ icon := string(GetStandardIconCode("01d", "openweather")) // default to clear sky
+
+ if len(weatherData.Weather) > 0 {
+ description = weatherData.Weather[0].Description
+ icon = string(GetStandardIconCode(weatherData.Weather[0].Icon, "openweather"))
+ }
return &WeatherData{
// ... other fields ...
- Description: weatherData.Weather[0].Description,
- Icon: string(GetStandardIconCode(weatherData.Weather[0].Icon, "openweather")),
+ Description: description,
+ Icon: icon,
}, nil🔗 Analysis chain
Validate or document assumptions about weatherData.Weather array.
By design, OpenWeather often includes at least one weather entry, but there's no explicit check guarding against the case where weatherData.Weather could be empty. If the API unexpectedly returns an empty array, referencing weatherData.Weather[0] could cause an out-of-bounds panic.
A possible defensive fix:
-if len(weatherData.Weather) > 0 {
- description = weatherData.Weather[0].Description
- icon = GetStandardIconCode(weatherData.Weather[0].Icon, "openweather")
-}
+var description string
+var iconCode string
+if len(weatherData.Weather) > 0 {
+ description = weatherData.Weather[0].Description
+ iconCode = weatherData.Weather[0].Icon
+} else {
+ description = "N/A"
+ iconCode = "01d" // A sensible default or fallback
+}Let me verify the concern by searching for the usage of weatherData.Weather array in the codebase.
Let me check the implementation of the OpenWeather provider to see the full context of how the response is handled.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Error: No shell scripts found
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Search for files containing OpenWeatherResponse or weatherData.Weather
rg -l "OpenWeatherResponse|weatherData\.Weather"
# Search for the actual usage of weatherData.Weather array
rg "weatherData\.Weather" -A 5 -B 5
Length of output: 807
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Get the full implementation of the OpenWeather provider
cat internal/weather/provider_openweather.go
Length of output: 3373
| // YrNoSymbolToIcon maps Yr.no symbol codes to standardized icon codes | ||
| var YrNoSymbolToIcon = map[string]IconCode{ | ||
| "clearsky_day": "01", | ||
| "clearsky_night": "01", | ||
| "fair_day": "02", | ||
| "fair_night": "02", | ||
| "partlycloudy_day": "03", | ||
| "cloudy": "04", | ||
| "rainshowers_day": "09", | ||
| "rain": "10", | ||
| "thunder": "11", | ||
| "sleet": "12", | ||
| "snow": "13", | ||
| "fog": "50", | ||
| // Add more mappings as needed | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Check for missing nighttime entries.
While Yr.no symbol codes for daytime are covered (e.g., partlycloudy_day), the corresponding nighttime variant (partlycloudy_night) is absent. If Yr.no provides a distinct code for that condition, consider adding it for completeness.
"partlycloudy_day": "03",
+"partlycloudy_night": "03",
"cloudy": "04",📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| // YrNoSymbolToIcon maps Yr.no symbol codes to standardized icon codes | |
| var YrNoSymbolToIcon = map[string]IconCode{ | |
| "clearsky_day": "01", | |
| "clearsky_night": "01", | |
| "fair_day": "02", | |
| "fair_night": "02", | |
| "partlycloudy_day": "03", | |
| "cloudy": "04", | |
| "rainshowers_day": "09", | |
| "rain": "10", | |
| "thunder": "11", | |
| "sleet": "12", | |
| "snow": "13", | |
| "fog": "50", | |
| // Add more mappings as needed | |
| } | |
| // YrNoSymbolToIcon maps Yr.no symbol codes to standardized icon codes | |
| var YrNoSymbolToIcon = map[string]IconCode{ | |
| "clearsky_day": "01", | |
| "clearsky_night": "01", | |
| "fair_day": "02", | |
| "fair_night": "02", | |
| "partlycloudy_day": "03", | |
| "partlycloudy_night": "03", | |
| "cloudy": "04", | |
| "rainshowers_day": "09", | |
| "rain": "10", | |
| "thunder": "11", | |
| "sleet": "12", | |
| "snow": "13", | |
| "fog": "50", | |
| // Add more mappings as needed | |
| } |
| // Create new weather service | ||
| weatherService, err := weather.NewService(settings, dataStore) | ||
| if err != nil { | ||
| log.Printf("Failed to initialize weather service: %v", err) | ||
| return | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| wg.Add(1) | ||
| go func() { | ||
| defer wg.Done() | ||
| openweather.StartWeatherPolling(settings, dataStore, quitChan) | ||
| weatherService.StartPolling(quitChan) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codebase verification
Weather service initialization lacks resilience mechanisms
Based on the code analysis, the concern about lack of retry logic is valid. The findings show:
- The weather service initialization is a one-time attempt with no retry mechanism
- Other services in the codebase (FFmpeg, Wikipedia, database) implement retry/backoff patterns for resilience
- The weather service polling continues indefinitely once started, but if the initial setup fails, the service never recovers
Key locations that could benefit from retry logic:
internal/analysis/realtime.go: Add retry logic aroundweather.NewService()initializationinternal/weather/weather.go: Consider implementing backoff pattern similar to other services
🔗 Analysis chain
Successful transition to the new weather service
The code creates and starts the weather service with proper error handling. However, watch out for potential specific error types that might require a retry or a fallback approach. If initialization fails once, the service is never retried.
As a follow-up, consider exploring whether a limited retry logic or fallback is appropriate here to handle transient network/configuration issues.
Let me gather more information about the weather service implementation to better understand the initialization and error handling.
Let me check one more aspect about the weather service polling implementation.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Attempt to locate existing or partial retry logic that might overlap with weather initialization
rg -A 3 "retry"
Length of output: 4811
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check weather service implementation for any existing retry/recovery mechanisms
ast-grep --pattern 'type Service struct {
$$$
}'
# Look for weather service initialization and error handling patterns
rg -A 5 "NewService"
# Check for any backoff or retry utilities in the codebase
fd backoff
Length of output: 1165
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Check weather service polling implementation
rg -A 10 "StartPolling"
# Look for any recovery mechanisms in the weather service
rg -A 5 "recover" internal/weather/
Length of output: 1622
internal/conf/config.yaml
Outdated
| weather: | ||
| provider: yrno | ||
| pollinterval: 60 | ||
| debug: false |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Remove trailing spaces.
A static analysis tool (yamllint) flags trailing spaces here. Strip any extra whitespace to maintain YAML cleanliness.
- debug: false
+ debug: false📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| debug: false | |
| debug: false |
🧰 Tools
🪛 yamllint (1.35.1)
[error] 92-92: trailing spaces
(trailing-spaces)
… method - Implemented a safety check to handle cases where no weather conditions are returned from the OpenWeather API, preventing potential nil pointer dereferences and improving error handling.
Weather Provider Refactoring
Changes
Key Features
Technical Details